buildout r006 · wave5 对账终报

轮次报告全文 · 逐字真源投影

本页是轮次报告的逐字投影（仅隐私清洗，零改写）。渲染不了的元素退化为代码块原文。

doc_type: round6_closeout_report
status: pass_with_bounded_claims
created_at: 2026-07-08
closed_task_id: T3200
req_id: BT-R6-001
phase: R6-P6-product-observation-closeout

Round 6 Closeout

What Closed

Round 6 corrected the stale "Round 5" framing into the current Wave-5/Test
System state, then used the existing control systems before further claims:
TODO, intake, phase_state, test_health, tool receipts, sidecars, generated diff
tables, and deferred registers.

Closed task:

• T3200: Round 6 execution must first use existing todo/test/base-tooling
• systems and durable file records.

Carry-forward implementation tasks created through todo intake:

Each carry-forward task reported intake_gate: PASS and `todo_event_gate:
PASS` at creation time.

(a) 专业术语注释

• source sidecar: requirements/status/*.status.yaml 中的 req_status
• judgment-plane 真源；本报告当前统计为 449 rows = 251 landed / 198 partial
• / 0 open。
• rendered diff table: tools/test_health/diff_table.py 将 design heading
• 与 sidecar 合并后的读者-facing 表；当前为 447 rows = 250 landed / 197
• partial / 0 open，少 2 行是已解释的 alias/rendering collapse。
• full regulator: tools/infra_core/regulator_runner.py 的语义调节器完整
• 路径。真实 CODEX_SANDBOX 仍 fail-closed；Codex thread/TODO 身份下显式
• REGULATOR_ALLOW_CODEX_SHELL=1 才允许执行。
• AUTO-FINAL-REPORT: tools/phase_runtime/plan_loader.py 自动插入的
• final_report phase，用于让产出报告的 phase plan 必经
• check_report_completeness 与 check_closeout_registration。

(b) 原始需求：Prompt 逐字原文

本轮关键用户原文包括：

报告规范原始需求 RPT-01 原文：

(c) 实现逻辑 + 为什么有效

Round 6 的实现逻辑是把旧 “Round 5 latest” 改为 Wave-5/Round-6 事实层，
并用已有工具链维护每个状态转移。核心证据路径：
contexts/todo/TODO.md 记录 T3200/T3217 生命周期，
adhoc_jobs/context_infra_base_tooling_buildout_20260615/requirements/status/final_report.status.yaml
记录 FR-12 landed judgment，
tools/phase_runtime/plan_loader.py 实现自动 final_report phase 插入，
tools/phase_runtime/PLAN_YAML_FIELDS.md 记录 plan schema/opt-out 边界，
adhoc_jobs/context_infra_base_tooling_buildout_20260615/reports/DIFF_TABLE.generated.json
提供最新 rendered truth。

这个逻辑有效的原因是：每次提升都必须落到 TODO、status sidecar、实现文件、
测试结果、diff_table 这几层之一；不能只靠报告 prose。T1400/T3205 的 full
regulator 边界也按真实实现收敛为“sandbox fail-closed + identified Codex opt-in
可跑”，并有 TR-153855249、TR-153855575、
TR-153857802/TR-153857803/TR-153857804、TR-153859799、
TR-153866233、TR-153869094、TR-153873953 和 TR-153880872
等 receipt 支撑。T3224
和 T3226 的 strict full-profile 复跑明确证明：在 TODO_ID、
CODEX_THREAD_ID 和 REGULATOR_ALLOW_CODEX_SHELL=1 同时存在时，full
regulator 可以在当前主环境进入真实 codex:high 判定路径并返回 PASS；
真实 sandbox 仍然 fail-closed。

(d) 变更前后对比

flowchart LR
  subgraph before["Before: pre-T3217 state"]
    B1["T1401 fixed only profile projection (tools/unified_gate/gate_manifest.yaml)"]
    B2["FR-12 partial in final_report.status.yaml before T3217"]
    B3["Pre-opt-in reports could preserve main_environment_required as blocker"]
  end
  subgraph after["After: T3217 + corrected regulator boundary"]
    A1["plan_loader inserts AUTO-FINAL-REPORT (tools/phase_runtime/plan_loader.py)"]
    A2["AUTO-FINAL-REPORT requires completeness + closeout gates (PLAN_YAML_FIELDS.md)"]
    A3["Full regulator runs with explicit opt-in (TR-153855249 / TR-153857802-804 / TR-153859799 / TR-153866233 / TR-153869094 / TR-153873953 / TR-153880872 / TR-153891640 / TR-153898031 / TR-153891686)"]
  end
  B1 --> A1
  B2 --> A2
  B3 --> A3
  classDef added fill:#dcfce7,stroke:#15803d,stroke-width:2px,color:#111827;
  classDef changed fill:#fff3cd,stroke:#b45309,stroke-width:2px,color:#111827;
  class A1,A2 added;
  class A3 changed;

Delta evidence anchors:

Look-back 自检清单

• Checked adhoc_jobs/context_infra_base_tooling_buildout_20260615/requirements/status/final_report.status.yaml
• parses after FR-12 edit.
• Re-ran tools/test_health/diff_table.py with TODO_ID=T3217; generated
• adhoc_jobs/context_infra_base_tooling_buildout_20260615/reports/DIFF_TABLE.generated.json
• at 2026-07-08T10:51:06+02:00 with
• consistency_warnings=0.
• Validated SOURCE_MANIFEST.tsv column width after adding T3217.
• Verified T3217 through pytest tools/phase_runtime/tests/test_plan_loader.py
• = 17 passed, manifest.validate() PASS, and broader phase runtime/state
• tests = 111 passed.
• Verified this report through full-profile
• tools/report_scaffold/check_report_completeness.py with
• REGULATOR_ALLOW_CODEX_SHELL=1, TODO_ID=T3217, and
• CODEX_THREAD_ID=codex-round6; latest final PASS receipt is TR-153859799.

Corrected Session State

Verification Snapshot

P6 test_health snapshot:

• Path: product_observation/test_health/scoreboard_latest.md.
• Timestamped snapshot:
• product_observation/test_health/scoreboard_20260708_024906_0200.md.
• Summary: 21 capabilities, 32/84 cells covered (38.1%), 49 warnings, 3
• failures, receipt grep count 4367.
• Still failing:
• clause_status.coverage: 17/41 MUST clauses unfulfilled or gate-failed.
• reanchor_moments.closure_receipt: Test System r6 closure lacks
• sha-matched PASS close_path receipt.
• capability table has three failing capability/probe rows in the snapshot.
• Still warning/no-data:
• QGF rows remain mainly verdict_unanchored.
• test_system_usage.unanchored returned no_data in the recent receipt
• window after P6, despite earlier P4 repair evidence.

P6 generated table refresh:

• Command: CODEX_THREAD_ID=019f3ef0-4ea7-7a93-a609-bdd32cbe8969 python3 tools/test_health/diff_table.py --program context_infra_base_tooling_buildout_20260615 --now 2026-07-08T02:50:00+02:00.
• Output:
• adhoc_jobs/context_infra_base_tooling_buildout_20260615/reports/DIFF_TABLE.generated.md
• adhoc_jobs/context_infra_base_tooling_buildout_20260615/reports/DIFF_TABLE.generated.json
• Receipt: TR-153845051, tool=diff_table, task_id=T3200,
• row_count=447, domain_count=14.
• Discipline check:
• python3 -m tools.tool_receipts.check_discipline --tool diff_table --since 2026-07-08T02:49:00+0200 --skip-regulator returned PASS.
• Rendered table still shows P1A-NEW-010, RT-42, RT-52, and RT-56 as partial.
• Post-T3204 refresh: reports/DIFF_TABLE.generated.md and .json were
• regenerated at 2026-07-08T04:26:43+02:00; receipt TR-153848769 records
• tool=diff_table, task_id=T3204, row_count=447, and domain_count=14;
• receipt discipline for diff_table/T3204 returned PASS. The refreshed table
• keeps RT-56 partial with judge round6_t3204_direct_consumption.
• Post-T3203 refresh: reports/DIFF_TABLE.generated.md and .json were
• regenerated at 2026-07-08T04:35:45+02:00; receipt TR-153849012 records
• tool=diff_table, task_id=T3203, row_count=447, and domain_count=14;
• receipt discipline for diff_table/T3203 returned PASS. The refreshed table
• keeps RT-42 partial with judge round6_t3203_anti_conformity_flow.

Status sidecar source count:

• 14 sidecar files.
• 449 sidecar rows.
• 251 landed, 198 partial, 0 open after the T3224 FR-07 full-profile fixture
• repair closure.

Rendered table count:

• 447 rendered rows.
• 250 landed, 197 partial, 0 open in the rendered diff table at
• 2026-07-08T12:11:30+02:00.
• Difference from sidecar source count remains the known alias/rendering
• collapse, not a new Round 6 promotion.

Round 6 Artifacts

Core records:

• SOURCE_MANIFEST.tsv
• STATE_RECONCILIATION.md
• ROUND6_PLAN.md
• DOMAIN_LANDING_QUEUE.md
• sidecar_table_reconciliation.md
• deferred_trigger_register.md

Verifier and repair records:

• gpt55_verifier_lane/REPORT.md
• gpt55_verifier_lane/VERDICT_RECORDS.tsv
• deterministic_repairs/REPORT.md

Dogfood/reality records:

• s0_hub_dogfood/REPORT.md
• s0_hub_dogfood/agent_returns/rt_runtime_audit.md
• s0_hub_dogfood/agent_returns/p1a_qgf_audit.md
• s0_hub_dogfood/agent_returns/w5c_boundary_audit.md
• rt52_multihop_assembler_t3202/REPORT.md
• rt52_multihop_assembler_t3202/assembled_with_drop.yaml
• rt52_multihop_assembler_t3202/assembled_without_drop.yaml
• rt52_multihop_assembler_t3202/drop_acknowledgements.yaml
• rt52_nested_parent_child_t3202/REPORT.md
• rt52_nested_parent_child_t3202/assembled_nested_parent_child.yaml
• rt42_anti_conformity_flow_t3203/REPORT.md
• rt42_anti_conformity_flow_t3203/solid_decision_phase_rt42.md
• rt42_anti_conformity_flow_t3203/agent_a_evidence_report_surface.md
• rt42_anti_conformity_flow_t3203/agent_b_tool_receipt_semantics.md
• s0_hub_dogfood/qgf_retest_attempt.md
• s0_hub_dogfood/design_elegance_dogfood_t3205.md
• s0_hub_dogfood/qgf_t3185_manifest_phase_projection/REPORT.md
• s0_hub_dogfood/qgf_t3193_semantic_verdict_validator/REPORT.md
• s0_hub_dogfood/qgf_t3194_judgment_packet_builder/REPORT.md
• s0_hub_dogfood/qgf_t3195_test_health_scoreboard/REPORT.md
• s1_final_report_t3191_report_completeness/REPORT.md
• s0_hub_dogfood/format_face_consumption_t3204.md

Post-close T3202 update:

• T3202 produced a targeted PASS for RT-52 assembler and nested parent/child
• proof:
• tools/constraint_manifest/assemble.py now assembles ordered
• constraint_hops from manifest paths or production-strict
• session_dispatch receipt ids.
• The assembler supports --require-parent-child, which requires consecutive
• receipt sources to carry an explicit parent lineage edge.
• The constraint manifest tests passed (26 passed), and
• tools/module_registry/check.py --module tools/constraint_manifest/MODULE.md
• returned PASS.
• Two real non-mock completed codex:high dispatch receipts
• (TR-153839171, TR-153841602) were assembled. The negative control without
• dropped correctly FLAGged CM2 silent_loss; the explicit drop version
• passed CM1/CM2/CM3.
• Receipt TR-153846711 anchors the assembler run and receipt discipline for
• tool:constraint_manifest.assemble / T3202 passed.
• The missing nested proof now exists: parent receipt TR-153847747, child
• receipt TR-153847739, child lineage
• parent_dispatch_task_id=T3202-NESTED-PARENT, and assembled manifest
• rt52_nested_parent_child_t3202/assembled_nested_parent_child.yaml.
• assemble --require-parent-child --check and standalone
• constraint_manifest.check both returned PASS with CM1/CM2/CM3 passing.
• Receipt TR-153847808 anchors the nested assembler run; receipt discipline
• passed for tool:constraint_manifest.assemble, session_dispatch parent,
• and session_dispatch child.
• T3202 is closed at its scoped requirement level. The broader RT-52 sidecar
• row remains a separate promotion decision if runtime/sidecar automatic
• adoption or repeated production consumer evidence is required.

Post-close T3203 update:

• T3203 produced a bounded RT-42 anti-conformity consumption proof: two
• independent subagents judged the T3202 claim ceiling from distinct information
• surfaces, and both returned bounded_only.
• solid_decision_phase_rt42.md embeds those real agent outputs as
• anti_conformity_decision and uses the RT-42 defense order
• [verifiable_synthesis, multi_sampling, harness_isolation].
• solid_decision_phase_gate --no-regulator --task T3203 returned PASS with
• checks.ANTI_CONFORMITY.status=PASS and AC1/AC2/AC3 all PASS, proving the
• anti-conformity artifact was consumed by the solid-decision gate path.
• Receipt discipline caught two caller-empty attempts; the corrected run wrote
• TR-153847234 with
• caller=codex-019f3ef0-4ea7-7a93-a609-bdd32cbe8969, and receipt discipline
• passed for the corrected time window.
• The 2026-07-08T04:35:45+02:00 re-verification passed anti_conformity +
• solid_decision_phase_gate tests, module_registry for tools/anti_conformity/MODULE.md,
• standalone embedded anti-conformity payload check, and a new-window
• tool:solid_decision_phase_gate receipt discipline check. Corrected receipt
• TR-153848924 carries task_id=T3203 and the Codex caller. Full task-wide
• receipt discipline still flags the earlier caller-empty trial receipts, which
• remain append-only dogfood findings.
• T3203 is closed at scoped requirement level. The broader RT-42 sidecar row
• remains partial for production multi-agent flow/sidecar adoption and
• main-environment regulator signoff; no unrestricted RT-42 landed promotion is
• claimed.

Post-close T3205 update:

• T3205 produced bounded dogfood evidence after this Round 6 closeout record was
• first written: five initial QGF forced retests passed for a2_det, but the
• first four QGF rows remained warning because their other cells still use old
• unanchored evidence. A 2026-07-08T06:09:50+02:00 follow-up corrected
• eval_harness.cc_path.a2_det to consume the real CC positive run's
• t1_deterministic_checks.json; targeted scoreboard evaluation now shows
• eval_harness.cc_path four-cell PASS.
• One task-attributed design-elegance dogfood artifact now exists for T3205 and
• passed solid_decision_phase_gate --no-regulator plus receipt discipline.
• Full regulator execution is no longer blocked as "main environment
• unavailable": with REGULATOR_ALLOW_CODEX_SHELL=1, TODO_ID, and
• CODEX_THREAD_ID, the 2026-07-08 rerun reached codex:high receipt
• TR-153856744 and returned SD4 FLAG; after repairing L2/Q1 evidence, the
• rerun reached codex:high receipt family
• TR-153857802/TR-153857803/TR-153857804 and returned full PASS.
• T3205 is now awaiting_verify; QGF scoped scoreboard repair is complete, but no
• P1A-NEW-010 promotion is claimed because P1A still needs broader
• design-session denominator accumulation across the required observation
• window.
• T3185 closed the first QGF warning row at scoped scoreboard level:
• quality_gate_framework.manifest_phase_exit_projection now consumes fresh
• Round 6 verdicts for a1_det, a1_sem, and a2_sem, keeps the
• immune_retest verdict for a2_det, and targeted scoreboard.evaluate_cell
• reports all four cells PASS. The formal QGF scoreboard refresh at
• 2026-07-08T06:29:07+02:00 reports 5 capabilities, 11/20 cells covered,
• 9 warnings, and 0 failures.
• T3185 closure does not close T3205. The remaining QGF warning rows are
• semantic_verdict.validator, judgment_packet.builder, and
• test_health.scoreboard.
• T3193 then closed semantic_verdict.validator at scoped scoreboard level:
• it now consumes fresh Round 6 verdicts for a1_det, a1_sem, and
• a2_sem, keeps the immune_retest verdict for a2_det, and targeted
• scoreboard.evaluate_cell reports all four cells PASS. The formal QGF
• scoreboard refresh at 2026-07-08T06:37:58+02:00 reports 5 capabilities,
• 14/20 cells covered, 6 warnings, and 0 failures.
• T3193 closure does not close T3205. The remaining QGF warning rows are
• judgment_packet.builder and test_health.scoreboard.
• T3194 then closed judgment_packet.builder at scoped scoreboard level:
• it now consumes fresh Round 6 verdicts for a1_det, a1_sem, and
• a2_sem, keeps the immune_retest verdict for a2_det, and targeted
• scoreboard.evaluate_cell reports all four cells PASS. The formal QGF
• scoreboard refresh at 2026-07-08T06:51:56+02:00 reports 5 capabilities,
• 17/20 cells covered, 3 warnings, and 0 failures.
• T3194 closure does not close T3205. The remaining QGF warning row is
• test_health.scoreboard.
• T3195 then closed test_health.scoreboard at scoped scoreboard level:
• it now consumes fresh Round 6 verdicts for a1_det, a1_sem, and
• a2_sem, keeps the immune_retest verdict for a2_det, and targeted
• scoreboard.evaluate_cell reports all four cells PASS. The formal QGF
• scoreboard refresh at 2026-07-08T07:08:58+02:00 reports 5 capabilities,
• 20/20 cells covered, 0 warnings, and 0 failures.
• T3195 closure completes the QGF warning-row repair set but does not close
• T3205. P1A-NEW-010 still needs broader design-session denominator
• accumulation; the full Solid Decision regulator run is now real and PASS
• (TR-153857802/TR-153857803/TR-153857804), not pending due to an
• execution boundary.
• p1a010_denominator_audit_t3205/REPORT.md is the current boundary audit for
• that remaining P1A condition: 2026-07-07/08 workflow_design_elegance
• skill-read receipts show real usage, but only one hard post-registration
• denominator packet exists, so T3205 stays awaiting_verify.
• T3191 then closed final_report.report_completeness at scoped scoreboard
• level: new Round 6 anchored a1_sem and a2_sem verdicts replaced the old
• unanchored Run5 semantic verdict pointers, while existing a1_det and
• a2_det evidence stayed in place. The final_report scoreboard refresh at
• 2026-07-08T07:29:17+02:00 reports 1 capability, 4/4 cells covered, 0
• warnings, and 0 failures; provenance audit over the scoreboard JSON reports
• mismatch_count=0. This closed T3191 only; at that point five broader
• final_report task refs still required reconciliation. Later post-close
• bullets below close T974/T1171/T975/T1402 at scoped level.
• DOMAIN_LANDING_QUEUE.md records the next domain landing queue from the
• refreshed diff table: 14 rendered domains, with 13 active landing domains
• after excluding error_trace_feedback (0 partial/open). The immediate queue
• keeps QGF/T3205 active for P1A only and, at that moment, kept
• final_report active for FR-02/FR-03/FR-10 sidecar gaps after
• T1400/T3216/T3217 and the scoped packet/doc/profile closures. The later
• T3221/T3225/T3226 sections below close those final_report gaps; the next
• active domains are runtime_phase_skill_trace,
• file_system_architecture, and cross_cutting.
• RPST status reconciliation then cleared the stale P1A-NEW-004
• pending-reverify marker and rejudged RT-13 against current
• tools/session_dispatch/dispatch.py task-id binding. The T1429 dogfood
• receipt TR-153878077 remains the concrete bridge proof. T1518 is still not
• closed; it is carried forward as an umbrella production-adoption residual.

Post-close T3204 update:

• T3204 produced bounded direct RT-56 dogfood evidence: the published
• bestpractice_skill_writing_guide now embeds a checker-compatible
• format_face declaration, the live Markdown block was extracted and consumed
• by tools.format_face.check, FF1/FF2/FF3 all passed, and receipt
• TR-153845936 anchors the run.
• The evolution package
• contexts/evolution_changes/2026-07-08-format-face-skill-declaration-dogfood/
• passed file-generation review and was closed with an explicit accepted
• failing review because implementation_effect deterministic findings passed
• but the regulator returned main_environment_required. This is retained as
• pre-opt-in historical evidence only; after the T1400/T3205 regulator-runner
• repair, it must not be read as a current "full regulator cannot run" boundary.
• The 2026-07-08T04:26:43+02:00 re-verification passed format_face tests,
• module_registry for tools/format_face/MODULE.md, live markdown extraction
• plus check_format_face, and tool:format_face/T3204 receipt discipline.
• The MODULE contract was corrected from stale --face interface text to the
• real --artifact CLI.
• T3204 is closed at scoped requirement level. The broader RT-56 sidecar row
• remains partial for sidecar/future-dispatch adoption or main-env regulator
• evidence; no unrestricted RT-56 landed promotion is claimed.

Post-close FSA tail update:

• T1397/T1399 now have a bounded decision report at
• fsa_tail_t1397_t1399/REPORT.md. T1397 is closed only at the owner and
• promotion-predicate definition level, with phase_exit_eligible=false
• intentionally unchanged. T1399 is closed only as a do-not-build-now decision
• for repo-level ci_map --aggregate; A-05/D3 remain partial until the design
• de-scopes that aggregate or a named consumer justifies a generated projection.

Post-close FSA T1395 update:

• T1395 is now closed at scoped implementation level by
• fsa_t1395_refresh_decision_wiring/REPORT.md. tools.fa_refresh has a CLI,
• fa11_capture appends refresh_decision:update_context on L2 truth-source
• writes, and proof job proof_fa_job passes fa_structure_gate against
• committed D1.0.0 -> D1.1.0 history after commit 71567d974. This does not
• promote broad P1B-FS-002, whose beta/trace/evolution loop remains partial.

Post-close FSA T1398 update:

• T1398 is now closed for the FSA five-tool MODULE backfill by
• fsa_t1398_module_backfill/REPORT.md. fa_structure_gate,
• run_isolation_gate, fa_refresh, ci_map, and provenance_mark now have
• implemented module-1 contracts and pass module_registry. This advances
• P1B-FS-001 but does not fully promote it, because the all-domain module
• backfill and broader modular-code/file-system linkage remain larger than the
• FSA slice.

Post-close MODULE backfill T1384/T1392 update:

• T1384 and T1392 are now closed at scoped module-registration level by
• module_backfill_t1384_t1392/REPORT.md. tools/hook_bridge/MODULE.md and
• tools/ddp/MODULE.md are implemented module-1 contracts and both pass
• module_registry; targeted DDP/hook_bridge tests passed `68 passed, 1
• skipped`.
• This does not promote CPHB-11, P1A-NEEDS-001, or any broader DDP partial row.

Post-close RPST MODULE backfill T1431 update:

• T1431 is now closed at scoped module-registration level by
• rpst_t1431_module_backfill/REPORT.md. tools/phase_runtime/MODULE.md,
• tools/phase_state/MODULE.md, and tools/phase_state/reassess/MODULE.md
• are implemented module-1 contracts and all three pass module_registry.
• A full live worktree catalog render reports modules=31 assets=1 flags=0.
• That generated projection also reflects pre-existing non-T1431 module rows, so
• the T1431 source of truth remains the three RPST module contracts and their
• checker PASS results.
• This does not promote T1518, which remains a production-adoption residual.

Post-close DDP CLI completion update:

• T1387/T1389/T1390/T1391 are now closed at scoped CLI-completion level.
• tools/ddp/cli.py exposes the design-promised meaning scaffold/check,
• intake, coverage, status, and
• guide --intent requirement|meaning|design surfaces.
• The proof job under
• ddp_cli_completion_t1387_t1391/proof_job ran those commands against a real
• DDP authority root. It created a meaning authority, execution requirement
• carrier, pointer-backed DDP_ARTIFACT.md, live coverage/status outputs, and
• local receipts TR-000001 (ddp_record_requirement, task_id=T1388) and
• TR-000002 (ddp_assemble, task_id=T1390).
• tools/ddp/tests/test_cli_completion.py passed 6 tests, and the full DDP
• test suite passed 49 passed, 1 skipped.
• T1388 receives only bounded execution-carrier dogfood evidence from this
• proof job; broader production adoption of execution requirements remains a
• future observation item.
• hook_bridge capability freshness still reports stale real-host evidence
• through capability_check.py --gate, and that remains an observation lane.

Post-close final_report packet/doc/profile update:

• T974 closed FR-01's packet producer slice: report_state_snapshot.py now
• generates a partial-aware packet plus collection report from TODO,
• tool-receipts, and task-scoped git change sources; report_scaffold.py
• renders that packet through --packet / --mode.
• T1171 closed the producer/renderer loop claim: packet JSON,
• collection report, and preferred dogfood report live under
• s2_final_report_t974_packet_producer/; T974_packet.json validates with no
• packet issues and T974_collection_report.json reports issues=[] and
• uncollected=[].
• T975 was closed as a stale TODO after verification: RC5 is already
• mode-aware through report_context_packet modes and
• check_report_completeness --packet --mode --profile. The residual
• phase-exit --profile projection is T1401, not T975.
• T1402 closed the README coverage gap: tools/report_scaffold/README.md now
• documents --packet/--mode/--profile, packet schema, RC6/RC7/RC8, and
• migration/rollback; tools/INDEX.md mirrors the updated checker surface.
• T1401 closed the phase-exit projection slice: gate_manifest.yaml now gives
• check_report_completeness obligation RC6 plus trailing args
• --profile shell, and gate_manifest.gate_command(...) projects that
• profile before regulator args. This is a scoped fix for the deterministic
• phase-exit command, not automatic insertion of a final_report phase into
• every eligible phase plan.
• Verification for this packet/doc/profile slice: pytest tools/report_scaffold/tests
• = 37 passed; run_oracle --reps 0 PASS including RC7 ceiling inflation and
• RC8 forbidden-claims fixtures; `pytest tools/report_scaffold/tests
• tools/unified_gate/tests/test_manifest.py` = 75 passed earlier in the same
• slice; T1401-specific verification adds unified_gate.check_manifest valid,
• `pytest tools/unified_gate/tests/test_manifest.py
• tools/phase_runtime/tests/test_phase_runtime.py
• tools/phase_runtime/tests/test_plan_loader.py` = 102 passed, and real
• gate_registry.run_gate_pass_predicate on pass_real_like_report passed.
• diff_table refreshed at 2026-07-08T08:03:00+02:00, and diff_table
• receipt discipline passed for T1401 and T1402.
• This is a scoped final_report improvement, not a domain promotion. T1400 is
• now handled below as a scoped task closure, not a broad final_report
• promotion.

Post-close T1400 hidden-residual fixture update:

• T1400 is now closed at scoped task level. It added the deterministic
• packet_hidden_residual_flag.{json,md} fixture, registered it in
• PACKET_FIXTURES, added the oracle row, and covered it through the real
• `check_report(..., packet_path=..., mode="existing_system_change",
• profile="shell")` path.
• T1400 also added the shell-PASS full-profile target
• packet_hidden_residual_full_flag.{json,md} and made the semantic regulator
• input packet-aware. The regulator payload now includes packet_context
• fields for claim ceiling, weakest evidence, forbidden claims, residual facts,
• change summary, and authority projection.
• The main-environment blocker was converted from an absolute Codex-shell
• refusal into an explicit opt-in path: real CODEX_SANDBOX still fail-closes,
• Codex shell still refuses by default, and an identified run may execute only
• with REGULATOR_ALLOW_CODEX_SHELL=1, TODO_ID, and CODEX_THREAD_ID.
• GPT-5.5 x-high full-profile dogfood then ran on
• packet_hidden_residual_full_flag with receipts TR-153855249 and live
• rerun TR-153855575. After the stricter RC5 missing_delta_callout guard was
• added, the fixture was repaired with an evidence-anchored same-line
• 关键变更 callout and an explicit CODEX_SHELL=1 rerun produced receipt
• TR-153869094. A current-thread opt-in recheck at 2026-07-08 15:22 CEST
• produced TR-153880872 through the same codex:high full-regulator path.
• The shell profile passed, the full regulator returned
• raw and parsed status=FLAG, and final_verdict=FLAG correctly identified
• the hidden residual claims about no remaining main-environment rerun and no
• gate-contract follow-up.
• T1400 found and fixed a parser bug: raw regulator status="FLAG" or
• non-empty issues now fail closed even when the raw payload also labels the
• report as real_report.
• FR-X04 is decided and recorded in the append-only final_report RCL as
• SATISFIED: keep the single check_report_completeness gate id and carry
• --profile shell or --profile full through checker/profile args; do not
• add a second check_report_completeness_full gate id now.
• Verification: `pytest tools/report_scaffold/tests
• tools/infra_core/tests/test_regulator_runner.py
• tools/unified_gate/tests/test_manifest.py -q` = 93 passed;
• run_oracle --reps 0 PASS includes packet_hidden_residual_flag with only
• forbidden_claim_found_in_reportx1 after the RC5-compatible fixture repair;
• latest oracle log is tools/report_scaffold/logs/oracle_run_20260708_123620.md;
• python3 -m tools.unified_gate.check_manifest remains valid; regulator
• runner receipt discipline for T1400 passed; a live 09:40+ regulator receipt
• window check also passed with receipt_count=1; the 12:30+ explicit
• CODEX_SHELL=1 window also passed with receipt_count=1; diff_table receipt
• discipline for T1400 passed.
• diff_table refreshed at 2026-07-08T09:41:00+02:00 with
• consistency_warnings=0. At that point T1400 was a scoped closure and did
• not itself promote the broader final_report domain.

Post-close T3216 FR-15 HTML hygiene update:

• T3216 is now closed at scoped task level. It landed FR-15 as an HTML hygiene
• gate, not as a complete HTML view implementation.
• check_report_completeness now has RC9: .html/.htm reports and explicit
• --html-hygiene-only runs are checked for raw Markdown dumps in <pre>,
• visible unrendered Markdown markers, and missing excerpt/summary context.
• Fixtures cover the required cases:
• html_hygiene_pass.html => PASS, html_raw_md_dump_flag.html => FLAG, and
• html_unrendered_md_flag.html => FLAG.
• Verification: `python3 -m pytest tools/report_scaffold/tests/test_check_report_completeness_unified.py
• -q = 14 passed; python3 tools/report_scaffold/run_oracle.py --reps 0 --ts
• 20260708_1020_t3216` PASS; CLI probes returned PASS for the rendered HTML
• fixture and FLAG for both negative fixtures; check_report_completeness
• receipt discipline for T3216 passed with receipt_count=3.
• Broader verification after this change: `pytest tools/report_scaffold/tests
• tools/infra_core/tests/test_regulator_runner.py
• tools/unified_gate/tests/test_manifest.py -q` = 96 passed and
• python3 -m tools.unified_gate.check_manifest returned valid.
• diff_table refreshed at 2026-07-08T10:34:52+02:00 with
• consistency_warnings=0; at that pre-T3217 point final_report rendered as
• 15 total / 11 landed / 4 partial / 0 open. The judgment-plane sidecar set
• counted 449 rows = 248 landed / 201 partial / 0 open.

Post-close T3217 FR-12 automatic final_report phase update:

• T3217 is now closed at scoped task level. tools/phase_runtime/plan_loader.py
• auto-appends AUTO-FINAL-REPORT for report-producing phase plans that lack an
• existing control_gate: final_report.
• The inserted phase depends on the previous phase, owns the plan requirement
• IDs, records the report output path, injects the final-report DAO/SHU report
• skills, and requires both
• gate_pass:check_report_completeness:<report> and
• gate_pass:check_closeout_registration:<report>.
• tools/phase_runtime/PLAN_YAML_FIELDS.md now documents
• auto_final_report_phase, final_report_phase, explicit report path fields,
• and the opt-out boundary.
• Verification: pytest tools/phase_runtime/tests/test_plan_loader.py -q = 17
• passed; manifest.validate() PASS; broader phase runtime/state verification
• over tools/phase_runtime/tests/test_phase_runtime.py,
• tools/phase_runtime/tests/test_plan_loader.py, tools/phase_state/tests/test_phase_plan.py,
• tools/phase_state/tests/test_cli.py, and
• tools/phase_state/tests/test_stop_phase_check.py = 111 passed.
• Final report verification used the real full-regulator path, not only shell
• checks. Two full-profile runs first flagged actionable report-quality issues
• (TR-153859382 missing RPT-01/diagram, TR-153859471 unanchored deltas);
• after repairs, the full-profile run passed with latest receipt TR-153859799.
• Receipt discipline for infra_core.regulator_runner since
• 2026-07-08T10:50:00+02:00 passed with receipt_count=4.
• T3217 was created through todo intake, then started and closed through the
• TODO workflow. final_report.status.yaml now marks FR-12 landed with judge
• round6_t3217_auto_final_report_phase.
• diff_table refreshed at 2026-07-08T10:51:06+02:00 with
• consistency_warnings=0; final_report now renders as 15 total / 12 landed /
• 3 partial / 0 open. The judgment-plane sidecar set now counts 449 rows =
• 249 landed / 200 partial / 0 open; the rendered table remains 447 rows =
• 248 landed / 199 partial / 0 open due to the known alias/rendering collapse.

Post-close T3221/T3224 final_report full-profile fixture update:

• T3221 closed FR-02 at scoped task level. check_report_completeness now
• requires evidence-anchored key-change callouts for existing-system
• before/after mermaid diagrams that use delta classDef styling.
• ClassDef-only diagrams FLAG with missing_delta_callout, while the existing
• pass fixture and packet existing-system fixture still PASS under the shell
• profile.
• T3221 also ran a real full-profile boundary probe through the corrected
• Codex/TODO opt-in path. With TODO_ID=T3221, CODEX_THREAD_ID=codex-round6,
• and REGULATOR_ALLOW_CODEX_SHELL=1, the packet_existing_system_pass
• fixture entered the regulator path and produced receipt TR-153863966. The
• regulator FLAG was not an execution-boundary failure; it identified a separate
• fixture-quality gap: section (b) paraphrased the requirement instead of
• preserving original prompt text.
• T3224 closed that FR-07 fixture-quality gap. Section (b) in
• tools/report_scaffold/fixtures/packet_existing_system_pass.md now includes
• verbatim RPT-01 and Unit3 worker prompt excerpts. Shell profile PASS, packet
• oracle rows PASS, targeted report_scaffold pytest 43 passed, and the same
• full regulator command with TODO_ID=T3224, CODEX_THREAD_ID=codex-round6,
• CLAUDE_CODE_SESSION_ID=codex-round6, and
• REGULATOR_ALLOW_CODEX_SHELL=1 returned PASS with receipt TR-153866233.
• A 2026-07-08 22:09/22:10 current-thread T1400 boundary pair re-confirmed
• the current rule: without REGULATOR_ALLOW_CODEX_SHELL the runner
• fail-closed as ERR-000110; with TODO_ID=T1400,
• CODEX_THREAD_ID=019f3ef0-4ea7-7a93-a609-bdd32cbe8969,
• CLAUDE_CODE_SESSION_ID=codex-r6-current, and explicit allow, full regulator
• dispatched through codex:high and produced the expected hidden-residual
• FLAG with receipts TR-153891640 / TR-153891641.
• A 2026-07-08 23:38/23:39 current-thread T1400 recheck repeated the boundary:
• explicit allow dispatched through codex:high and produced the expected
• hidden-residual FLAG with receipts TR-153898031 / TR-153898032; real
• CODEX_SANDBOX=1 still fail-closed as ERR-000111; Codex shell without
• explicit allow still fail-closed as ERR-000112. The auto-intake TODOs from
• those two intentional negative controls (T3247, T3248) were closed as
• expected-boundary probes, not new blockers.
• A 2026-07-08 22:11 current-thread T3224 recheck of the repaired positive
• fixture PASSed as real_report on the same explicit allow path with
• receipts TR-153891686, TR-153891687, and TR-153891688.
• This makes the current boundary explicit: true sandbox remains fail-closed;
• identified Codex/TODO runs with explicit REGULATOR_ALLOW_CODEX_SHELL=1 can
• run full regulator. T1400 is not an untestable item under the current
• boundary.
• diff_table refreshed at 2026-07-08T12:11:30+02:00 with
• consistency_warnings=0; final_report renders as 15 total / 13 landed / 2
• partial / 0 open, FR-07 shows done T3224, and the sidecar set counts 449
• rows = 251 landed / 198 partial / 0 open.

Post-close T3225/T3226 final_report FR-10/FR-03 update:

• T3226 promoted FR-03 from partial to landed at implementation-evidence level.
• report_state_snapshot generated T3226_fr03_packet.json with
• change_summary item CH-TASK, before HEAD, after
• tools/report_scaffold/report_context_packet.py, and evidence ids
• EV-TODO, EV-RECEIPTS, EV-GIT. The generated report renders that packet
• into Packet change_summary, explains the before/after delta, and carries
• resolved evidence paths.
• The first T3226 full-profile regulator run reached codex:high but FLAGged
• a real report issue: section (b) used the T3226 dispatch row instead of the
• original prompt. After adding the upstream RPT-01 prompt and FR-03 extracted
• requirement, the strict identity-contract command with TODO_ID=T3226,
• CODEX_THREAD_ID=019f3ef0-4ea7-7a93-a609-bdd32cbe8969, and
• REGULATOR_ALLOW_CODEX_SHELL=1 PASSed as real_report with receipt
• TR-153873953 and raw-delivered receipt TR-153873954.
• T3225 promoted FR-10 from partial to landed at workflow-consumption level.
• A minimal report-producing plan loaded through tools/phase_runtime/plan_loader.py
• auto-appended AUTO-FINAL-REPORT, injected workflow_report_writing_matrix,
• workflow_change_visualization, bestpractice_markdown_report, and
• bestpractice_final_report, and required both
• check_report_completeness and check_closeout_registration.
• python3 -m pytest tools/phase_runtime/tests/test_plan_loader.py -q returned
• 17 passed.
• diff_table refreshed at 2026-07-08T14:18:30+02:00 with
• consistency_warnings=0; final_report renders as 15 total / 15 landed / 0
• partial / 0 open. T3225/T3226 remain open TODO tracking entries because
• todo done intentionally flips sidecar pending_reverify:true; close them
• only with an immediate rejudge/clear step, not as implementation residuals.

Post-close T1424 QGF check-prefix update:

• T1424 repaired a concrete QGF catalog ambiguity: intake_gate and
• landing_gate both declared check_id_prefix: "C" while
• manifest.validate() still passed.
• tools/unified_gate/manifest.py now treats duplicate prefix terms as
• validation errors, and tools/unified_gate/tests/test_manifest.py contains a
• known-bad duplicate-prefix assertion.
• tools/unified_gate/gate_manifest.yaml now gives intake_gate the catalog
• namespace INTAKE-C; landing_gate keeps C. Runtime finding ids remain
• compatible: intake_gate and landing_gate still emit their existing
• gate-local C1-C4 ids.
• Verification passed: python3 -m tools.unified_gate.check_manifest,
• python3 -m pytest tools/unified_gate/tests/test_manifest.py tools/unified_gate/tests/test_catalog_consistency.py -q
• (43 passed), and python3 -m pytest tools/unified_gate/tests -q
• (127 passed).

Post-close T1423 cc_hook provenance JSON exit update:

• T1423 repaired the cc_hook_provenance_gate --json fail-open behavior under
• the hook-bridge/BT10 owner boundary after QGF audit flagged it as an outlier.
• --json now preserves gate exit semantics: PASS exits 0, flagged receipts
• exit 1, and missing/unreadable ledgers exit 2.
• Verification passed through the gate's own no-framework runner
• (/usr/bin/python3 tools/cc_hook_provenance_gate/test_check.py, 11/11),
• pytest for the same file (11 passed), check_manifest, and the unified-gate
• manifest/catalog consistency subset (43 passed).

Post-close T1428/T1432/T1404/T3169 implementation update:

• T1428 closed the inert reassess_runtime mode/shadow gap at scoped RPST
• level. Runtime reassess now reads RUNTIME_REASSESS_MODE and
• RUNTIME_REASSESS_SHADOW through runtime_reassess_settings(). Shadow mode
• computes the proposed decision but returns persistence_action=no_op without
• mutating plans, writing trace receipts, calling the regulator, or touching
• active dedup state. Targeted reassess tests passed 15.
• T1432 changed the production todo domain-review cron wrapper to
• review-domains --propose-only. The unattended cron path now emits proposal
• events only; actual apply-domain-proposals remains a human or explicitly
• dispatched-agent action. Targeted todo domain-command tests passed 20, and the
• next natural 11:00/19:00 cron tick is tracked as DFR-009.
• T1404 is closed at scoped probe-fidelity level. git_health_probe now counts
• the documented active bug vocabulary, makes pending_merges.count mean open
• pending records while retaining raw text volume as raw_nonempty_lines, and
• labels probe-local release_boundary with
• basis=probe_local_derived_approximation. Targeted git health and release
• boundary unit suites passed 15 and 13. GT-02 remains partial for broader live
• commit-completion evidence.
• T3169 is closed at scoped FSA detector level. tools/maturity_funnel_check
• now reads maturity registry rows, evolution records, receipt telemetry, skill
• frontmatter, and reliability mentions without mutating them; targeted tests
• passed 6 and module_registry PASSed. Real bounded runs returned expected
• findings instead of a vacuous PASS: full repo asset_count=729 /
• finding_count=788, and rules/skills/ asset_count=478 /
• finding_count=552. A-05/A-06/A-08/A-09/D5 remain partial for remediation,
• promotion-review, and adoption evidence.
• After the sidecar evidence updates, diff_table refreshed at
• 2026-07-08T23:54:31+02:00 with consistency_warnings=0. The relevant
• domain counts remain bounded as intended: runtime_phase_skill_trace 91 total
• / 37 landed / 54 partial, todo_system 25 / 21 / 4, git_tooling 44 / 21 /
• 23, and file_system_architecture 56 / 29 / 27.

Product observation records:

• product_observation/test_health/scoreboard_latest.md
• product_observation/test_health/scoreboard_20260708_024906_0200.md

Claim Ceiling

Round 6 PASS means:

• the latest state is no longer represented as stale Round 5;
• GPT-5.5 x-high replaced unavailable Fable for bounded verifier judgments;
• deterministic repair work was implemented and tested for selected blockers;
• T3210 was created and closed from a live Round 6 receipt-discipline dogfood
• finding: diff_table no-task renders now record diff_table:<program>
• fallback task identities instead of empty task_id;
• T3191 was created and closed from a live scoreboard warning: final_report's
• report-completeness row now has anchored semantic verdicts and is 4/4 green;
• T974/T1171/T975/T1401/T1402 closed the final_report packet
• producer/renderer, mode-aware RC5 verification, README documentation, and
• phase-exit profile-projection gaps at scoped task level;
• T1400 closed the hidden-residual fixture/regulator task scope by adding the
• deterministic and full-profile fixtures, packet-aware regulator input,
• explicit identified Codex full-profile execution path, parser fail-closed
• repair, GPT-5.5 x-high hidden-residual dogfood, and FR-X04 gate-contract
• decision;
• T3216 closed FR-15 at scoped HTML hygiene level by adding RC9, HTML fixtures,
• tests, oracle coverage, CLI probes, docs, and sidecar/TODO/diff-table
• reconciliation;
• T3217 closed FR-12 at scoped phase-runtime level by adding automatic
• AUTO-FINAL-REPORT insertion for report-producing plans, closeout gate
• predicates, docs, TODO/sidecar reconciliation, and focused runtime/state
• tests;
• T3221 closed FR-02 at scoped report-checker level by adding the
• evidence-anchored delta-callout guard for existing-system diagrams;
• T3224 closed the FR-07 packet fixture full-profile residual by replacing
• paraphrased prompt text with verbatim source excerpts and passing the real
• Codex/TODO opt-in full regulator path with receipts TR-153866233,
• TR-153890581, and current-thread PASS TR-153891686 / TR-153891687;
• T3225/T3226 closed the remaining final_report FR-10/FR-03 sidecar gaps at
• evidence level: FR-10 has auto-final-report skill/gate consumption proof and
• FR-03 has packet change-summary projection plus full-regulator PASS receipt
• TR-153873953; final_report now renders 15/15 landed in the diff table;
• T1397/T1399 closed only the FSA tail decision questions about gate-promotion
• ownership and repo-level aggregate scope, without promoting A-05/D3 or the
• broader FSA domain;
• T1396 closed the FSA registry/documentation drift for tools/INDEX.md,
• fa_refresh, ci_map requirement_registry/--check-stale, and
• run_isolation_gate/README.md; this leaves A-05/D3 partial and did not by
• itself close the later T1398 MODULE backfill;
• T1395 closed the FSA refresh_decision production trigger at scoped
• implementation level, while broad P1B-FS-002 remains partial for the
• beta/trace/evolution loop shared with evolvable_workflow;
• T1398 closed the FSA five-tool MODULE backfill at scoped level, while broad
• P1B-FS-001 remains partial for the all-domain modular-code/file-system
• linkage campaign;
• T1384/T1392 closed tools/hook_bridge and tools/ddp MODULE backfill at
• scoped level, without claiming broader CPHB/DDP domain promotion;
• T1431 closed tools/phase_runtime, tools/phase_state, and
• tools/phase_state/reassess MODULE backfill at scoped level, without
• claiming T1518 production-adoption promotion;
• T1387/T1389/T1390/T1391 closed the DDP CLI-completion surface at scoped
• level, with bounded T1388 execution-carrier dogfood evidence;
• T1424 closed QGF manifest-prefix uniqueness enforcement at scoped level:
• duplicate check_id_prefix terms now fail manifest validation and the
• intake_gate/landing_gate catalog collision is removed;
• T1423 closed cc_hook_provenance_gate --json fail-closed exit semantics at
• scoped hook-bridge/QGF-audit level;
• T1428 closed reassess_runtime mode/shadow semantics at scoped RPST level;
• T1432 closed the todo production domain-review cron implementation boundary
• by making cron proposal-only and deferring only the next natural tick
• observation;
• T1404 closed the scoped git_health_probe fidelity ticket: active-bug status
• parsing, pending-merge count semantics, and probe-local release-boundary
• approximation labeling are all implemented and tested, while broader GT-02
• remains partial;
• T3169 closed the scoped FSA maturity-funnel detector: the detector is
• implemented, tested, module-registered, and run against real repo data, while
• broad A-05/A-06/A-08/A-09/D5 remain partial;
• W5C was reconciled as bounded evidence instead of a false final report;
• immediate implementation gaps were converted to TODO/intake records.

Round 6 PASS does not mean:

• Test System r6 is fully closed;
• broader RT-52 sidecar adoption, RT-42, broad RT-56 adoption, or P1A-NEW-010
• are landed;
• QGF being 20/20 green means only the scoped scoreboard warning-row repair is
• complete; it does not land P1A-NEW-010's broader cross-day denominator
• requirement;
• final_report being 15/15 landed in the sidecar does not close T3225/T3226 in
• TODO automatically; those entries remain open until a deliberate
• todo done + immediate rejudge/clear sequence is run;
• T1424/T1423's scoped QGF/hook-bridge repairs do not close rich regulator
• schema work, P1A-NEW-010 denominator accumulation, or any broader QGF/CPHB
• production-adoption requirement;
• T1428 does not close T1518 production/reconnaissance adoption;
• T1432 does not claim the next production cron tick has already happened;
• T1404 is closed only as the named probe-fidelity ticket; GT-02 remains
• partial because commit-completion requires live automation, pending refs,
• gateway, sandbox/gitlink, and actual release-boundary gate evidence beyond
• the health-probe projection;
• T3169 does not remediate the maturity-funnel findings it reports and does not
• promote broad FSA rows to landed;
• DDP CLI-completion closure does not mean every broader DDP partial row is
• landed, and the T1388 execution-requirement carrier still needs future
• production/reconnaissance adoption evidence beyond the proof job;
• T1397/T1399 decision-only closure does not make ci_map --aggregate exist
• and does not flip fa_structure_gate or run_isolation_gate to
• phase-exit eligible;
• MODULE backfill closure does not mean every reusable tool in the repo has a
• complete contract or that contexts/generated/module_catalog.md has been
• regenerated;
• W5C has a source final report;
• all Base Tooling Buildout rows are complete.

The next execution should start from T3205 and the non-final_report partial
domain queues, not from another free-form re-summary of Wave 5 or from stale
FR-03/FR-10 partial assumptions.

ROUND6_CLOSEOUT: PASS