Run3 · final_report 域收口报告

Z3 全文↑ Z2 条目

轮次报告全文 · 逐字真源投影

本页是轮次报告的逐字投影（仅隐私清洗，零改写）。渲染不了的元素退化为代码块原文。

时点提示：本页是仓内文件 adhoc_jobs/context_infra_base_tooling_buildout_20260615/Run3/reports/DOMAIN_final_report_CLOSURE_REPORT.md 的逐字投影（仅做隐私清洗：仓库根绝对路径→相对路径、家目录→~/；除此零改写）。若源文件后续有修订，以仓内真源为准。

Run3 final_report Closure Report

domain: final_report
scope closed: FR-S1 / Slice 1 only
verdict: PASS_BOUNDED
claim ceiling: bounded
closure date: 2026-07-02

What Closed

FR-S1 landed the final-report evidence backbone:

tools/report_scaffold/report_context_packet.py: packet schema, canonical dump/load, and deterministic validation.
tools/report_scaffold/check_report_completeness.py: packet-aware --packet / --mode / --profile shell path with RC5 mode dispatch, RC6 evidence resolution, RC7 claim-ceiling checks, and RC8 forbidden-claim checks.
tools/report_scaffold/run_oracle.py: packet fixture registry.
Packet fixtures: existing-system and greenfield PASS fixtures plus unresolved-evidence, ceiling-inflation, and missing-forbidden-claims FLAG fixtures.

Landed commits:

6ec3d5b5d - disposition and initial RCL.
992c217c7 - packet schema and tests.
efe4c79df - packet checks wired into report gate.
3f1c1a579 - packet oracle fixtures.
aa247d034 - eval_harness consumption and real A/B evidence.

Verification

Mechanical checks:

python3 tools/report_scaffold/run_oracle.py --reps 0 --ts final_report_closure_verify passed all 11 oracle rows: existing 6 text fixtures plus 5 packet fixtures.
python3 -m pytest tools/report_scaffold/tests passed: 23 tests.
Unit verification records exist under Run3/run_artifacts/final_report/verification/ for schema, gate integration, and oracle fixtures.

Consumption and A/B:

Run3/run_artifacts/final_report/eval_harness/capture.jsonl
Run3/run_artifacts/final_report/eval_harness/pre_snapshot.json
Run3/run_artifacts/final_report/eval_harness/isolation_check.md
Run3/run_artifacts/final_report/eval_harness/oracle_verdict.json
Run3/run_artifacts/final_report/eval_harness/real_condition_ab/oracle_verdict.json

The eval_harness verdict is PASS. The real-condition A/B result is positive PASS and negative FLAG with rc6-unresolved-evidence issues, which is the expected fail-closed behavior.

Domain Evaluation

Independent evaluations:

Run3/run_artifacts/final_report/evaluations/EVAL_codex_high.md: verdict: PASS_BOUNDED; it reran oracle and packet tests.
Run3/run_artifacts/final_report/evaluations/EVAL_claude_zai_high_narrow.md: verdict: PASS_BOUNDED; it independently read bounded evidence and closure caveats.
Run3/run_artifacts/final_report/evaluations/EVAL_opencode_high.md: verdict: PASS_BOUNDED; it independently checked scope, packet fixtures, eval_harness artifacts, and negative RC6 behavior.

Non-accepted broad claude-zai and claude-kimi attempts are retained only as worker-prompt trace. They are not counted as closure evidence.

The Codex and opencode evaluators flagged the same administrative caveat: aggregate GAP-FR-001 was still IN_FLIGHT before closure. That is now closed in Run3/rcl/final_report.jsonl; later-slice residuals remain separate DEFERRED_WITH_BOUNDARY rows.

RCL State

Run3/rcl/final_report.jsonl is closed for this bounded slice:

GAP-FR-001: SATISFIED
FR-S1-U1 through FR-S1-U6: SATISFIED
FR-X01, FR-X03, FR-X04, FR-X05, FR-X07, FR-X09: DEFERRED_WITH_BOUNDARY

There are no SATISFIED rows carrying residual gaps.

Residual Table

id	state	boundary
FR-X01	DEFERRED_WITH_BOUNDARY	`unified_gate.base` migration waits for quality_gate_framework-owned substrate migration and parity tests.
FR-X03	DEFERRED_WITH_BOUNDARY	Full `report_state_snapshot` auto-collection waits for upstream domains to expose real collectible records.
FR-X04	DEFERRED_WITH_BOUNDARY	Gate id/profile pinning waits for FR-S1/FR-S3 dogfood evidence.
FR-X05	DEFERRED_WITH_BOUNDARY	`tools/final_report` facade waits for packet/gate dogfood and stable profile shape.
FR-X07	DEFERRED_WITH_BOUNDARY	Skill-routing docs wait for FR-S1/FR-S2 shipped CLI and stable packet fields.
FR-X09	DEFERRED_WITH_BOUNDARY	Plan-loader enforcement remains rejected unless a new design reopens loader behavior.

Caveats

This closure does not prove organic adoption, cross-domain integration, production-final readiness, FR-S2 producer/rendering, FR-S3 semantic hidden-residual regulation, FR-S4 default plan insertion, FR-S5 unified-gate/doc/facade work, or any other domain's closure.

The strongest supported claim is: FR-S1 makes final-report packet evidence and shell-profile deterministic checks landed, tested, consumed through eval_harness, and verified by positive/negative replay under a bounded claim ceiling.

← 返回报告库 · Base Tooling buildout 轮次